Media Mutt

Story on Monks’ Book Lacks Details and Disclaimer

The rich get different treatment: On August 11, the New York Times published a lengthy article on Millicent Monks’ new book, Songs of Three Islands, and its painful details about her prominent family’s history of mental illness.

MaineToday Columnist vs. MaineToday Board Member

Fine line: Dan Billings writes a monthly column for the Morning Sentinel and Kennebec Journal, two papers owned by MaineToday Media.

Quality Work From a Maine Daily and Weekly

Behind the numbers: The Bangor Daily News’ Kevin Miller did a first-rate job of separating fact from fiction in his August 21 story on Republican gubernatorial candidate Paul LePage’s impact on Waterville’s finances during his tenure as that city’s mayor (“Candidate Paul LePage: the Wizard of Waterville”).

Press Herald Fails to Follow Up on Plagiarism

Letting Leigh lie: As reported here last week, the Portland Press Herald dismissed freelance columnist Leigh Donaldson after discovering he had borrowed liberally and without attribution from another writer’s work for an August 2 piece about scams against the elderly.

News Judgment Switch at the Press Herald

Confused news: Early on August 8, state Rep. Sean Flaherty of Scarborough was arrested for driving while intoxicated, after he crashed his car on Interstate 295 in Freeport. The next day, the Portland Press Herald reported the incident in a news brief.

Portland Ratings “Embargoed,” Then Leaked

No numbers … for one day: The Arbitron ratings for Portland radio stations were released to subscribers on August 10, but, in a break from past practice, the figures weren’t made public. The numbers from the spring survey of listeners are being “embargoed,” according to one station general manager who asked not to be identified, because “half the market is not subscribing [to Arbitron] this year.”

Press Herald Columnist Canned for Unattributed Info

Ethical lapse: According to an editor’s note in the August 9 Portland Press Herald, the paper has permanently parted ways with local columnist Leigh Donaldson.

The note says Donaldson’s August 2 column headlined “Increased vulnerability to scams is a disease of old age” (the piece is no longer posted on the paper’s Web site) contained “a substantial amount of content” taken without attribution from material originally published on AlterNet.org.

Dempsey Challenge Goes Unchallenged in Maine Media

The Maine media seems to have serious blind spots in their coverage of any group claiming to do good works. Whether it’s shipping medical supplies to Haiti, providing specialized care to children in China, or raising funds for a cancer-care center here at home, news outlets tend to trip all over themselves to provide services normally associated with lobbyists and public-relations flacks.

Maine Political Coverage: A Little Good, A Lot of Bad

Real reporting, but not much of it: On August 2, Gov. John Baldacci announced several nominations for important posts that should have gotten even an average reporter’s journalism glands secreting. That’s because at least two of the nominees came with some serious baggage.

But with the exception of the Bangor Daily News’ Kevin Miller, no reporters bothered to follow up.

Just Because a Maine Pol Said It, Doesn’t Make It So

On July 30, the Bangor Daily News ran an op-ed by former state controller Edward Karass questioning some of the claims made by Republican gubernatorial candidate Paul LePage. In the piece, Karass delves into LePage’s assertions that as mayor of Waterville, he cut property taxes and improved the city’s bond rating.

Syndicate content