Al Diamon
How Good Was Caldwell's 'Get'?
Rob hobnobs: Rob Caldwell, co-host of WCSH-TV’s and WLBZ-TV’s magazine show “207,” scored a “get” (industry talk for an interview with a sought-after figure) on Sept. 10, when he hooked up via satellite with Republican presidential candidate John McCain.
Caldwell was obviously well prepared for the occasion, asking pointed questions about national security, vice-residential pick Sarah Palin’s qualifications and the passing over of Maine senators Olympia Snowe and Susan Collins for the veep slot. Even though he failed to follow up on a couple of topics, he elicited a number of revealing answers and even caught McCain in an inconsistency or two. Solid work.
Big-time bloggers took note, although the Huffington Post, in chiding McCain for some minor errors, managed to get the name of Caldwell’s station wrong.
A couple of people have contacted me gushing about the story and suggesting I single Caldwell out for praise. “Rob was much tougher on McCain than any national TV reporter I've seen,” one of his fans wrote to my editor. “The guy has some chops.”
I can understand this adoration, even if I don’t agree with it. It’s so rare to see a competent local TV interview that when one comes along there’s a tendency among viewers to crank the praise dial all the way up to superlative.
Take a deep breath, folks. This is the way all interviews are supposed to be conducted. Your threshold for excellence has been tamped down because so many TV reporters attempt to interrogate people without doing any homework. They often don’t appear to have a clue about a story’s background, a subject’s role in it, or the difference between breaking new ground and rehashing what’s already been reported elsewhere. As long as they have video of the accident scene and a couple of taking heads saying almost anything, they figure they’ve done their jobs.
Caldwell approached the McCain interview with a measure of professionalism that ought to be the industry standard, rather than a rarity. He didn’t raise the bar, but maybe he’ll inspire others to stop banging their well-coifed heads on it every time they stick a microphone in somebody’s face.
Wack’s back: Kevin Wack, the former Portland Press Herald political reporter, has a new – although temporary – gig. Wack took a voluntary buyout offer during the Press Herald’s June round of layoffs and has moved on to the blogosphere.
For the next eight weeks, he’s covering the Maine U.S. Senate campaigns of Democrat Tom Allen and Republican Susan Collins for his blog called “The Maine Race.”
Those of us who recall Wack’s anemic efforts at blogging on the Press Herald’s Web site might be less than excited, but, if the early postings on the new blog are any indication, we’ll have to reassess. Wack’s latest work is sharp and informed, offering original insights (did you know that in all of Maine’s history, no 1st Congressional District representative – the position Allen currently holds – has ever won a Senate seat? I didn’t) and frequent updates. It’s a welcome addition to this year’s otherwise-thin political coverage.
Better enjoy it while you can, though. After the election, Wack is scheduled to start a nine-month fellowship program for journalists on Capitol Hill. After that, he said, “I'll be looking for work, and I don't know whether I'll be back in Maine.”
Press compressed: The Maine Press Association, the industry group that represents the state’s paid-circulation dailies and weeklies, is attempting to interest its members in news sharing. While some papers are already swapping stories on a limited basis (the Bangor Daily News and the Lewiston Sun Journal, for instance), the MPA envisions a more elaborate system that might help pick up the slack for publications that can no longer afford to cover as much as they once did.
To that end, the association is sponsoring a seminar on news sharing at its October conference in Bar Harbor.
Ben Marrison, editor of the Columbus Dispatch, will discuss how news outlets in his state set up the Ohio News Organization (which goes by the unfortunate acronym OHNO) to share stories.
One other note on the MPA event: The keynote speaker will be Lou Ureneck, chairman of Boston University’s Department of Journalism.
Ureneck is also a former editor of the Portland Press Herald, which should give him an interesting perspective on the current turmoil at his old stomping ground.
Mess assessed: Speaking of the Press Herald, the latest spasm in the ongoing battle between the paper’s owner and its largest union came on Sept. 10, when the two sides agreed to speed up the arbitration process.
The dispute centers around whether the Newspaper Guild’s contract with the paper remains in effect if the paper is sold. Blethen Maine Newspapers, the Press Herald’s owner, claims that forcing a potential buyer to accept the deal, which runs through 2011, would make it impossible to sell the Press Herald. Blethen sued the Guild in June in federal court seeking to have a judge declare that the contract didn’t apply to any new owners or to force the union to expedited arbitration to settle the issue.
The two sides are scheduled to report back to the court early next year, but Blethen has said it must settle the issue before then, because it’s continuing to lose money.
According to publisher Charles Cochrane, “The resolution of this matter will help bring certainty that will hopefully allow us to advance the sale exploration process.”
Al Diamon can be e-mailed at aldiamon@herniahill.net.
Posted on Friday, September 12, 2008 in Permalink
Views expressed in this blog belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect either Down East's editorial stance or the views of Down East Enterprise. We ask that comments be civil; anyone who refuses to self edit runs the risk of being banned from commenting on Down East.com content. Further, please limit material cited from other publications to fewer than 75 words and a link; anything more riles copyright attorneys.
Reader Comments:
Reading Wack's new blog one has to wonder if it's PPH policy to stomp the life out of its reporters' copy. I mean, the reporting and editorial decisions are uninspiring, but generally speaking the PPH writing is duller than a plastic knife.
Maybe Wack is just reinvigorated. Or maybe we're seeing his real ability.
This news-sharing thing sounds quite a lot like what the newspapers pay the Associated Press for.
—John Lovell
I wonder how reporters will be compensated for the reprinting of their material elsewhere, if at all?
This also reeks of a cost-cutting move.
Why should two or three papers send reporters to a meeting or event if they can send just one and share the report? That may save the bottom line for publishers, but it will hurt the product be reducing the number of voices reporting the news.
Caldwell's get? That's not a get. It's a sat tour. A get would be if Caldwell left the office and tracked down McCain on the campaign trail. Putting all that aside, why does this blogger feel empowered to comment on the activities of a broadcast journalist? Has he ever worked in the media? It's like asking a plumber to talk about brain surgery.
"Reeks of a cost-cutting move..." Well, duh. It's called survival. A daily newspaper in Maine will close within the next five years -- I'm in the biz, and I'm sure of that. Any way to cut costs makes sense, and it looks like a move to cut the costs of the AP, which is next to worthless in this state these days. The AP doesn't staff weekends, has only a few reporters on around the state and isn't the value it was years ago. And now the AP takes stories from papers, as part of the cooperative agreement, re-casts them, takes out any in-story mention of the source media and broadcasts it for other members to use. So TV stations, Radio and (to a degree) other newspapers can grab the stories and report on them, often tacitly taking credit for other organizations' hard work. I think this concept, at least, could start to change the game.
How will reporters be compensated? By having places to work at ....