Up Is Down, Wrong Is Right


Who doesn’t read the Lewiston Sun Journal?

Its editors, apparently.

If they did, they might have noticed a couple of errors in the main headline on the front page of the May 20 edition. That banner, above a story about the proposed state budget, read, “Spending up, taxes level.”

Here’s the second paragraph of that story:

“The biennial budget package represents an overall reduction in state spending from the previous biennium.”

So much for “Spending up.”

Later in the piece, readers are told that the budget will suspend the indexing of income-tax brackets for inflation, which “would result in an average increase of $12 or $13 for each Maine income tax filer affected.” In all, the story says, 450,000 people will pay more.

So much for “taxes level.”

This isn’t the first time I’ve taken the Sun Journal to task for sloppy editing, but this is certainly the most egregious recent example. This paper needs to improve its quality control in a hurry.

Otherwise, so much for credibility.

Al Diamon can be e-mailed at aldiamon@herniahill.net.

The views expressed on this Web site are those of the authors alone and do not necessarily represent the views of Down East Enterprise or its employees.

An update

The Sun Journal published a correction in its May 21st edition, stating the headline should have read, "Spending down, taxes up." On the paper's Web site, the headline was also changed to that more accurate version, but no mention of the correction was made, nor is the admission of error posted online. Considering the magnitude of the mistake, this limited attempt at mitigation isn't all that impressive.

Al Diamon

Okay, so the Sun Journal

Okay, so the Sun Journal headline made two claims, and both of them were untrue. On the plus side, though, the headline did not misspell "spending," "up," "taxes" or "level."